i was not present at the interview that took place between poirot and that strange man—alexander bonaparte cust. owing to his association with the police and the peculiar circumstances of the case, poirot had no difficulty in obtaining a home office order—but that order did not extend to me, and in any case it was essential, from poirot’s point of view, that that interview should be absolutely private—the two men face to face.
he has given me, however, such a detailed account of what passed between them that i set it down with as much confidence on paper as though i had actually been present.
mr cust seemed to have shrunk. his stoop was more apparent. his fingers plucked vaguely at his coat.
for some time, i gather, poirot did not speak.
he sat and looked at the man opposite him
the atmosphere became restful—soothing—full of infinite leisure…
it must have been a dramatic moment—this meeting of the two adversaries in the long drama. in poirot’s place i should have felt the dramatic thrill.
poirot, however, is nothing if not matter-of-fact. he was absorbed in producing a certain effect upon the man opposite him.
at last he said gently:
‘do you know who i am?’
the other shook his head.
‘no—no—i can’t say i do. unless you are mr lucas’s—what do they call it?—junior. or perhaps you come from mr maynard?’
(maynard & cole were the defending solicitors.)
his tone was polite but not very interested. he seemed absorbed in some inner abstraction.
‘i am hercule poirot…’
poirot said the words very gently…and watched for the effect.
mr cust raised his head a little.
‘oh, yes?’
he said it as naturally as inspector crome might have said it—but without the superciliousness.
then, a minute later, he repeated his remark.
‘oh, yes?’ he said, and this time his tone was different—it held an awakened interest. he raised his head and looked at poirot.
hercule poirot met his gaze and nodded his own head gently once or twice.
‘yes,’ he said. ‘i am the man to whom you wrote the letters.’
at once the contact was broken. mr cust dropped his eyes and spoke irritably and fretfully.
‘i never wrote to you. those letters weren’t written by me. i’ve said so again and again.’
‘i know,’ said poirot. ‘but if you did not write them, who did?’
‘an enemy. i must have an enemy. they are all against me. the police—everyone—all against me. it’s a gigantic conspiracy.’
poirot did not reply.
mr cust said:
‘everyone’s hand has been against me—always.’
‘even when you were a child?’
mr cust seemed to consider.
‘no—no—not exactly then. my mother was very fond of me. but she was ambitious—terribly ambitious. that’s why she gave me those ridiculous names. she had some absurd idea that i’d cut a figure in the world. she was always urging me to assert myself—talking about will-power…saying anyone could be master of his fate…she said i could do anything!’
he was silent for a minute.
‘she was quite wrong, of course. i realized that myself quite soon. i wasn’t the sort of person to get on in life. i was always doing foolish things—making myself look ridiculous. and i was timid—afraid of people. i had a bad time at school—the boys found out my christian names—they used to tease me about them…i did very badly at school—in games and work and everything.’
he shook his head.
‘just as well poor mother died. she’d have been disappointed…even when i was at the commercial college i was stupid—it took me longer to learn typing and shorthand than anyone else. and yet i didn’t feelstupid—if you know what i mean.’
he cast a sudden appealing look at the other man.
‘i know what you mean,’ said poirot. ‘go on.’
‘it was just the feeling that everybody else thoughtme stupid. very paralysing. it was the same thing later in the office.’
‘and later still in the war?’ prompted poirot.
mr cust’s face lightened up suddenly.
‘you know,’ he said, ‘i enjoyed the war. what i had of it, that was. i felt, for the first time, a man like anybody else. we were all in the same box. i was as good as anyone else.’
his smile faded.
‘and then i got that wound on the head. very slight.but they found out i had fits…i’d always known, of course, that there were times when i hadn’t been quite sure what i was doing. lapses, you know. and of course, once or twice i’d fallen down. but i don’t really think they ought to have discharged me for that. no, i don’t think it was right.’
‘and afterwards?’ asked poirot.
‘i got a place as a clerk. of course there was good money to be got just then. and i didn’t do so badly after the war. of course, a smaller salary…and—i didn’t seem to get on. i was always being passed over for promotion. i wasn’t go-ahead enough. it grew very difficult—really very difficult…. especially when the slump came. to tell you the truth, i’d got hardly enough to keep body and soul together (and you’ve got to look presentable as a clerk) when i got the offer of this stocking job. a salary and commission!’
poirot said gently:
‘but you are aware, are you not, that the firm whom you say employed you deny the fact?’
mr cust got excited again.
‘that’s because they’re in the conspiracy—they must be in the conspiracy.’
he went on:
‘i’ve got written evidence—written evidence. i’ve got their letters to me, giving me instructions as to what places to go to and a list of people to call on.’
‘not writtenevidence exactly—typewrittenevidence.’
‘it’s the same thing. naturally a big firm of wholesale manufacturers typewrite their letters.’
‘don’t you know, mr cust, that a typewriter can be identified? all those letters were typed by one particular machine.’
‘what of it?’
‘and that machine was your own—the one found in your room.’
‘it was sent me by the firm at the beginning of my job.’
‘yes, but these letters were received afterwards. so it looks, does it not, as though you typed them yourself and posted them to yourself?’
‘no, no! it’s all part of the plot against me!’
he added suddenly:
‘besides, their letters wouldbe written on the same kind of machine.’
‘the same kind, but not the same actual machine.’
mr cust repeated obstinately:
‘it’s a plot!’
‘and the a b c’s that were found in the cupboard?’
‘i know nothing about them. i thought they were all stockings.’
‘why did you tick off the name of mrs ascher in that first list of people in andover?’
‘because i decided to start with her. one must begin somewhere.’
‘yes, that is true. one must begin somewhere.’
‘i don’t mean that!’ said mr cust. ‘i don’t mean what you mean!’
‘but you know what i meant?’
mr cust said nothing. he was trembling.
‘i didn’t do it!’ he said. ‘i’m perfectly innocent! it’s all a mistake. why, look at that second crime—that bexhill one. i was playing dominoes at eastbourne. you’ve got to admit that!’
his voice was triumphant.
‘yes,’ said poirot. his voice was meditative—silky. ‘but it’s so easy, isn’t it, to make a mistake of one day? and if you’re an obstinate, positive man, like mr strange, you’ll never consider the possibility of having been mistaken. what you’ve said you’ll stick to…he’s that kind of man. and the hotel register—it’s very easy to put down the wrong date when you’re signing it—probably no one will notice it at the time.’
‘i was playing dominoes that evening!’
‘you play dominoes very well, i believe.’
mr cust was a little flurried by this.
‘i—i—well, i believe i do.’
‘it is a very absorbing game, is it not, with a lot of skill in it?’
‘oh, there’s a lot of play in it—a lot of play! we usedto play a lot in the city, in the lunch hour. you’d be surprised the way total strangers come together over a game of dominoes.’
he chuckled.
‘i remember one man—i’ve never forgotten him because of something he told me—we just got talking over a cup of coffee, and we started dominoes. well, i felt after twenty minutes that i’d known that man all my life.’
‘what was it that he told you?’ asked poirot.
mr cust’s face clouded over.
‘it gave me a turn—a nasty turn. talking of your fate being written in your hand, he was. and he showed me his hand and the lines that showed he’d have two near escapes of being drowned—and he had had two near escapes. and then he looked at mine and he told me some amazing things. said i was going to be one of the most celebrated men in england before i died. said the whole country would be talking about me. but he said—he said…’
mr cust broke down—faltered…
‘yes?’
poirot’s gaze held a quiet magnetism. mr cust looked at him, looked away, then back again like a fascinated rabbit.
‘he said—he said—that it looked as though i might die a violent death—and he laughed and said: “almostlooks as though you might die on the scaffold,” and then he laughed and said that was only his joke…’
he was silent suddenly. his eyes left poirot’s face—they ran from side to side…
‘my head—i suffer very badly with my head…the headaches are something cruel sometimes. and then there are times when i don’t know—when i don’t know…’
he broke down.
poirot leant forward. he spoke very quietly but with great assurance.
‘but you do know, don’t you,’ he said, ‘that you committed the murders?’
mr cust looked up. his glance was quite simple and direct. all resistance had left him. he looked strangely at peace.
‘yes,’ he said, ‘i know.’
‘but—i am right, am i not?—you don’t know why you did them?’
mr cust shook his head.
‘no,’ he said. ‘i don’t.’
